Serene L.

The arrival fallacy: why success can feel empty

Why the glow fades so fast, and what to do instead of chasing the next finish line.

You get the promotion, the offer, the number in the bank. For a day or two it feels wonderful. Then a quieter voice asks: what's next?

That flatness isn't ingratitude. Two well-studied patterns explain most of it.

Two reasons the glow fades

The first is adaptation, often called the hedonic treadmill. A big part of how good something feels depends on the contrast with what came before, and the contrast fades as the new situation becomes normal.

The second is what the psychology writer Tal Ben-Shahar calls the arrival fallacy: the belief that once you reach a particular destination you'll be happy for good. We picture the finish line as a place. In practice it's a moment, and the moment passes.

Maximizers and satisficers

Researchers have studied two styles of decision-making. Maximizers want the best possible option and search exhaustively for it. Satisficers, a word coined by the economist Herbert Simon, look for an option that meets their criteria and stop when they find one.

In The Quiet Art of Enough, Serene L. argues that moving toward the second style doesn't mean lowering your standards. It means deciding on them before you start searching.

A question to try

Before your next big goal, write down what “enough” would look like, in concrete terms, and what you'd do with the time and energy left over once you reach it.